Lydia has no context for the supernatural...yet. That there might be something supernatural at play here isn't something that would occur to her. She looks up at him intently, taking his cheeks in her hands.

"Think really hard. Is there anyone who might be trying to mess with you? Anybody who has some kind of issue with your mom...or your dad, maybe? I mean, he is in law enforcement."

But it doesn't feel like the right answer, even as she says it.